-Lucretia Stanhope
Katie nestled between library shelves, cradling a bakery box like a precious egg from Miss Withering’s upstairs collection. Dim light from the Tiffany lamp cast dancing shadows on the cardboard. The sweet scent of cake mingled with the stale air of old paper and pungent incense.
With a red-tipped nail, Katie carefully peeled off the sticker. The slight ripping sound broke the library’s silence. White cream cheese icing kissed the air with its sugary breath, whispering “Eat me.”
Showing less restraint than Alice would have in Wonderland, Katie removed the extra large slice, letting the box drop to her feet with a muffled thud. She smashed a bite against the roof of her mouth. The velvety icing melted into the rich, moist chocolate cake. Flavors mingled in a symphony of sweetness. She swallowed with the unchewed eagerness of a child.
A soft moan escaped her lips as she opened her mouth to shovel in the next bite.
Miss Withering’s black cat Peggy darted past, her sleek fur brushing against Katie’s leg before jumping onto the nearby shelf.
Katie gasped.
Cake lodged in her throat.
She stood, patting her chest as she forced the swallow.
Peggy pawed at one of the cracked and faded old leather books, sending it hurtling toward the floor.
Katie helplessly watched the book tumble end over end, crashing onto the hardwood with a resonant thud that echoed throughout the room. She glanced toward the ceiling, holding her breath while straining to hear Miss Withering’s bell.
The last bite of cake mocked Katie from her palm, its sugary scent still tantalizing her nose.
“Nasty creature,” Katie muttered while swatting at Peggy.
Peggy slinked out of reach, stopping to hiss before disappearing around the corner.
After finishing the last bite, Katie gathered the incriminating bakery box and left the book to pick up once she could clean her sticky fingers. Not that Miss Withering would stroll the library any time soon. Not ever, if Katie had any say in the matter.
The intricate carpet, thick and ancient, muffled her steps as she ambled down the hall toward the kitchen to prepare their official dinner.
Eyes in the portraits of the home’s previous caretakers seemed to follow her every move. Their gazes were cold and judgmental as if they had somehow witnessed her sneaking back to the kitchen to gorge on pizza after the old bat went to bed.
“The pictures will be the first to go after the house is mine,” she muttered.
Peggy zipped by, a blur of fur, wiggling between Katie’s legs.
Katie fell, catching herself with her hands. Pain lanced up her arm. The braided rug scraped off the skin on her palm, leaving it raw and stinging.
“You!” She glared at the cat.
From day one, Peggy had been hissing, tripping her, and tearing up her things. It was as if the cat knew that if the will hadn’t stipulated that she kept her, she’d be gone before the pictures.
In the kitchen, Katie pulled out the sanctioned meal, preparing two plates. One for her to shuffle food around on and one for Miss Withering.
The smell of boiled vegetables and bland chicken broth filled the room, turning her stomach. There was no doubt the mandatory diet she agreed to when she signed on as Miss Withering’s live-in aid and servant was healthy and probably why the old thing was pushing ninety, but it was nasty.
In her second year, when Katie found out she was the sole inheritor, she was glad she had put up with all the eccentric rules. At least to the old woman’s face. She could shuffle a bit of kale into her mouth for a multimillion-dollar estate.
She sprinkled something extra into Miss Withering’s soup, the fine powder dissolving quickly.
As Katie loaded the tray, Peggy jumped onto the counter, her eyes gleaming with malice.
Katie hissed at the cat. “You can’t save her. And then it’s to the pound with you. I hope the people who adopt you are jerks.”
Mindful of the nasty cat, Katie navigated the stairs.
Shadows clung to the corners. The wooden steps creaked beneath her weight.
It wouldn’t take many more meals, she thought. Once Katie decided to add her special seasoning, no amount of vegetables would keep that old ticker ticking. Though Miss Withering had lasted longer than Katie anticipated.
That was probably good. Since she’d been bedridden, the doctor had made several visits, commenting each time that he didn’t give her much longer and how surprised he was at her longevity. Lingering as long as she had cast less suspicion on Katie, but her patience was wearing thin.
As she reached the top of the stairs, a gust of wind rattled the windows, making the house seem as if it were alive, watching her with a malevolent interest. The draft carried the faint scent of decay, a reminder of the old woman’s imminent departure.
Katie couldn’t help but smile. Soon, it would all be hers.
With the tray balanced on her arm, Katie rapped on the doorframe, the cold wood under her knuckles a stark contrast to the warm, suffocating air inside the room.
Miss Withering peered toward Katie as if she hadn’t been waiting and listening to her every step. Heaps of pillows surrounded Miss Withering, appearing as if they were attempting to devour her slight frame.
The room smelled of a nauseating blend of stale air and medicine that clung to everything.
A breath rattled through Miss Withering’s chest, followed by a cough that sounded like dry leaves being crushed underfoot. “Come in.” The words were weaker today, barely more than a whisper.
Katie crossed to the bed, placing the tray on the dresser. The clink of porcelain against the tray echoed in the silence, a blunt reminder of the fragile life that lingered in the room. Miss Withering watched her with the heavy attentiveness reserved for fusty governesses, her eyes sharp and probing.
“How are you feeling today?” Katie asked as she pulled the chair over. Moving the chair was more of a habit now that Miss Withering wasn’t leaving the bed. The wood creaked under her weight.
“I’m sure it won’t sadden you that this is our last meal.” Miss Withering’s hand trembled as she smoothed her shirt. The fabric rustled like dry parchment.
Changing her from nightshirt into a housedress was also more for routine’s sake. “Let’s not be morbid. Dr. Hindemith says your stubbornness could see you to a hundred. I’ll bake your birthday cake myself.”
Miss Withering ate the bite of soup Katie offered. The silver spoon trembled as it approached her lips, releasing a wisp of steam that carried the faint scent of chicken broth. “No cake, dear. You know we must take care of these bodies we’re gifted.”
Yes, mustn’t forget, cake is the devil’s food. She thought of the delicious cake she had indulged in earlier, its sweetness lingering on her tongue. Katie filled the spoon again, her smile masking the impatience gnawing at her insides.
After eating the remainder of her soup in silence, Miss Withering closed her eyes. “Bring me Peggy. It’s time.”
“Do you want me to call the doctor? Are you feeling unwell?” Katie left the dish on the tray and returned to her side. The floorboards creaked under her feet.
“Bring me Peggy.” Miss Withering cracked an eye. “Leave the tray. You’ve done enough.”
Was that an accusation? Did the old bat know Katie was hastening her departure? “I’ll try. She’s not exactly fond of me.” Katie didn’t have to tell her that. Miss Withering knew her cat hated Katie. Hell, the little black devil cat hated Miss Withering too. Probably because she fed her some all-natural disgusting-smelling kibbles.
“Bring her to me.” Miss Withering’s demand held an authority that commanded obedience, even under its trembling strain.
The room grew colder. Shadows lengthened as if responding to the old woman’s will.
Katie hesitated.
Miss Withering turned away, dismissing her.
In the silence of the hall, Katie listened for sounds that might give away Peggy’s location. It wasn’t going to be easy. The slinky demon had no problems sneaking up on her.
The manor made its usual whispers as it settled and readjusted itself. Once it was Katie’s, there would be television and music masking the ghostly sounds. If she stayed. Depending on what she could get for the place, she might be able to afford a nice warm island of her very own where she’d let her staff eat whatever the hell they wanted while she sipped colorful drinks.
Cat first.
The hallway stretched endlessly in both directions. Thankfully, apart from Miss Withering’s room, all the doors were shut and off-limits.
She made her way to the stairs, glad Miss Withering was so private because the entire third floor was sealed as well. Peggy wasn’t in the hall, which meant she had to be on the bottom level.
At the bottom of the stairs, she closed the door.
“Make sure you keep doors closed.” Miss Withering’s instructions from day one so many years ago echoed in the silent hall.
Katie smiled when she glimpsed movement in the library. A faint light from inside struggled against the shadows. Katie hurried inside, closing the door behind her.
“Peggy?” She altered her voice to one she might have used if she liked the cat and added, “It’s time for your nasty kibbles.”
A soft hiss responded from the shadows.
She turned toward the sound.
Black streaked between the shelves.
Katie raced toward her.
Peggy crouched low, glaring at her with eyes that burned with malice.
“Come here, sweetie,” she coaxed, stepping closer.
Peggy’s ears flattened against her skull. She let out a low growl.
Katie reached out a tentative hand.
Claws flashed.
Pain seared through Katie’s wrist. Deep, bloody scratches appeared.
“Dammit,” she said, hissing, pulling her hand back and cradling it against her chest.
Peggy darted past, disappearing behind a shelf with a swish of her dark tail.
Katie bit her lip. Tears of pain and frustration welled in her eyes, but she pressed on. She couldn’t return empty-handed. Not when she was this close. One misstep and the will could be changed.
Beside Katie’s favorite reading nook, Peggy perched on a high shelf, staring down at her with a mix of defiance and fear.
“I don’t have time for this.” She grabbed a chair and dragged it over to the shelf. She climbed up and reached out, more determined this time.
Peggy hissed and swiped at her.
She dodged the claws and grabbed the cat firmly by the scruff of her neck.
Peggy writhed and yowled, her claws raking against Katie’s arms, leaving trails of blood in their wake.
Katie gritted her teeth and held on tight, despite the pain. She stepped down from the chair, struggling to keep a grip on the furious creature. As she exited the room, she closed the door behind her.
“Almost there,” she murmured, her voice shaking as much as her hands. She hurried down the hall, Peggy still fighting her every step of the way. She shouldered open the stairwell door and quickly shut it again, closing off all the escape routes.
Peggy yowled and writhed. Her hind claws managed to scratch Katie’s stomach through her shirt.
Katie tightened her grip on Peggy’s scruff. “Even if you get away, you’re pinned within the stairs and upper hall, beast.”
As if the cat could understand what she was saying, she stilled. The yowls changed to whines.
By the time she reached her mistress’s room, Katie’s arms were a mess of scratches and blood, and her face was pale with pain and exhaustion.
Miss Withering’s eyes brightened at the sight of Peggy.
“You got her,” the old woman whispered. A weak smile spread across her face, reaching her eyes with a spark of amusement.
“Yes, ma’am,” Katie replied, her voice barely more than a whisper. She set Peggy down on the bed.
Miss Withering rested a hand on the cat. “Imathal. Pervictus. Allimetrum.”
Katie stepped back, cradling her injured arms, and watched as the old woman pet the cat’s fur while muttering the same gibberish over and over. It was finally happening. Miss Withering was stroking out.
Peggy crawled up, nuzzling Miss Withering’s face in a never-before-seen show of affection.
Katie contemplated when she should call the doctor or 911. If it were a stroke, they could save her if Katie called too soon. She held her breath.
Miss Withering stopped murmuring. Her hand dropped.
Katie’s gut knotted.
Peggy turned toward her.
Was she purring?
Katie let out her breath and laughed. “I’m happy too, Peggy. Cake for everyone.” She laughed again.
Miss Withering’s eyes shot open. “Help me.”
Katie backed away, shaking her head.
The cat turned and hissed at Miss Withering.
“I’m Peggy,” Miss Withering said. She convulsed. When she stilled, she added, “Kill the cat.”
Katie’s attention ricocheted from the cat to the old woman in the bed.
“Witch.” The old woman gasped and rattled. “Kill it.”
The cat glared at Katie.
Was she smiling?
“I can’t.” Katie swallowed a knot of bile. Old people went insane when they died. Even if the cat was a witch, she wasn’t forfeiting her inheritance to kill it.
Miss Withering’s eyes went blank. She stilled.
This time she didn’t move again.
It didn’t take long after Katie called 911 and the doctor for them to arrive and declare Miss Withering dead.
Katie did her best impression of someone who gave a shit until everyone left her alone to mourn. While she debated how long she should wait to call the attorney about whatever she needed to do to get the ball rolling, she ordered pizza and cake.
In the kitchen, she made a bowl of tuna for Peggy.
“Here kitty, kitty,” she called. “Witchy little kitty.”
Peggy strolled in and rubbed against her legs.
Katie reached down to pet her.
Peggy gnashed into her finger.
“Imathal. Pervictus. Allimetrum.” The words echoed from everywhere and nowhere.
Gray ringed the edges of Katie’s vision. She dropped, her knees crashing onto the tiles before her face slammed into it, knocking her out.
“There, there, Katie,” a sweet young voice whispered.
Katie blinked her eyes open.
A hand stroked her back.
Katie glanced up at herself. “Am I dead?” Her question came out as a soft meow.
“Of course not. I’m not the murderer. You are. Poor Peggy. Don’t feel too bad. She had it coming. Killed an old lady, too.” The woman who looked just like Katie, even with fresh cuts from the day’s mishap, set a bowl of nasty kibble on the floor. “No tuna for you, dear. You know we must take care of these bodies we’re gifted. You must be especially careful with mine, being on its fifth life and all.”
Katie hissed understanding why Peggy was such a nuisance. This would be the witch’s last life if she had to murder every housekeeper that crossed the threshold.
The witch smiled at her as she dumped the pizza and cake in the trash. “I am truly grateful for your help. Unlike my littermates, I don’t really have a heart for murder, aside from a few mice and crickets. Thankfully, homicidal greed seems to be part of the human condition.”
LUCRETIA STANHOPE, a neurodiverse, relentlessly optimistic chronic illness warrior with less grace than determination, navigates her crone stage in a quaint Midwest town surrounded by cornfields. Amidst enduring medical trials that could rival horror stories, her pen never rests. When not lost in the wonderful lands of her imagination, she finds solace in doting on her three chihuahuas and her endlessly patient husband.